State of West Bengal v. Lala Mir Calcutta HC on POSH Act Section 9 Limitation

Factual Matrix of the Case

On August 31, 2026, a Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court comprising Hon’ble Justice Madhuresh Prasad and Justice Prasenjit Biswas delivered a vital judgment on workplace inquiry jurisdiction in State of West Bengal & Ors. v. Lala Mir & Ors. (WPST No. 250 of 2025; 2026:CHC-AS:1415-DB / 2026 SCC OnLine Cal 13644).

The case originated from a complaint filed under the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 (POSH Act) by a contractual Data Entry Operator deployed in the Criminal Investigation Department (CID), West Bengal. She alleged that between September 2021 and July 2022, the respondent (a Deputy Superintendent of Police) had touched her back and waist inappropriately while she was working at her computer. No specific dates within that ten-month span were identified in her complaint, and it was undisputed that no inappropriate act occurred after July 2022, following which she was assigned to a different section.

In October 2022, the complainant saw the respondent officer on the office premises when he returned from a three-month leave. No physical contact, verbal remark, or gesture occurred during that October 2022 sighting. However, the complainant stated that seeing him back in the office triggered a fear and apprehension in her mind that she might be reposted under him and subjected to similar conduct in the future. Relying on that October 2022 sighting, she submitted a written complaint to the Internal Committee (IC) on January 5, 2023.

The IC conducted an inquiry and issued an adverse report on April 13, 2023. The respondent officer challenged the proceedings before the West Bengal Administrative Tribunal (O.A. No. 450 of 2023). On June 19, 2025, the Tribunal quashed the IC report, holding that the complaint was time-barred under Section 9(1) of the POSH Act. The State of West Bengal filed a writ petition before the Calcutta High Court, contending that the complainant’s anxiety upon seeing the officer in October 2022 constituted a “recurring wrong” that brought the January 5, 2023 complaint within the three-month statutory limitation period.

Core Legal Ratio of the Division Bench

Dismissing the State’s writ petition and affirming the Tribunal’s order quashing the IC report, the Calcutta High Court laid down three clear principles governing POSH Act inquiries:

1. Subjective Apprehension Is Not an Incident of Sexual Harassment Under Section 2(n)

Section 2(n) of the POSH Act defines “sexual harassment” through concrete unwelcome acts or behaviour (whether directly or by implication), namely physical contact and advances, a demand or request for sexual favours, making sexually coloured remarks, showing pornography, or any other unwelcome physical, verbal, or non-verbal conduct of a sexual nature. While Section 3(2) recognizes an intimidating, offensive, or hostile work environment as an aggravating circumstance, Section 3(2) expressly requires that such circumstance must occur “in relation to or connected with any act or behaviour of sexual harassment”. The Bench held that merely seeing a former alleged perpetrator in the workplace after his return from leave, unaccompanied by any overt unwelcome act, word, or gesture, is a purely subjective internal apprehension and cannot constitute an “incident of sexual harassment” under Section 2(n).

2. Past Conduct vs. Continuing or Recurring Wrong

Applying the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s precedent affirming Dr. Nirmal Kanti Chakraborti v. Vaneeta Patnaik (2025 SCC OnLine SC 1964), the Division Bench distinguished between a completed past act and a continuing wrong. Because the last alleged unwelcome act took place in July 2022, subsequent workplace sightings or subjective anxieties could not be treated as a recurring wrong to keep the statutory limitation period open indefinitely.

3. Strict Computation of Limitation and the Discretionary Nature of the Section 9(1) Proviso

Under Section 9(1) of the POSH Act, an aggrieved woman must file a written complaint within three months from the date of the incident, and in the case of a series of incidents, within three months from the date of the last incident.

  • Condonation of Delay Is Discretionary, Not a Matter of Right: Under the second proviso to Section 9(1), the Internal Committee may extend the time limit by a further period not exceeding three months (creating an absolute outer statutory cap of six months from the last incident), only if the IC is satisfied that the circumstances were such that they prevented the woman from filing a complaint within the initial three-month period, and the reasons for such extension are recorded in writing by the IC.
  • The initial three-month period is the statutory rule; the additional three-month window is a strictly discretionary condonation power that requires proof of sufficient cause and a reasoned written order before the IC assumes jurisdiction. In Lala Mir, because the last alleged incident occurred in July 2022, the primary three-month period expired in October 2022, and the IC could not bypass limitation by treating an October 2022 corridor sighting as a fresh incident.

Operational Action Plan for Internal Committees and HR Heads [FREE]

When an Internal Committee conducts an inquiry into a complaint that is barred by limitation under Section 9(1), the entire report and consequential disciplinary penalties are rendered without jurisdiction and liable to be quashed in judicial review. Employers and IC Chairpersons must implement three procedural safeguards:

  • Perform a Mandatory Preliminary Limitation Scrutiny at Intake: Before issuing a notice to the respondent under Section 11, the IC must verify the exact date of the last overt unwelcome act falling within Section 2(n). Distinguish clearly between an actual overt incident and ongoing emotional apprehension or administrative transfer fears.
  • Pass a Formal Reasoned Order Before Condoning Delay Between Months 3 and 6: If a complaint is submitted after the expiry of three months from the last actual incident but within the six-month outer ceiling, the complainant cannot claim an extension as a matter of right. The IC must call upon the complainant to explain the circumstances that prevented timely filing, evaluate whether sufficient cause is established, and record a formal written order under the second proviso to Section 9(1) before proceeding with the inquiry.
  • Decline POSH Jurisdiction for Complaints Filed Beyond the 6-Month Outer Statutory Cap: Neither the IC nor the employer possesses statutory authority under the POSH Act to condone any delay beyond the maximum six-month period (three months initial period plus a maximum three-month discretionary extension). Time-barred or purely anticipatory complaints must be rejected under the POSH mechanism for want of statutory jurisdiction, while routing any administrative safety concerns or transfer requests through general HR grievance or Code of Conduct frameworks.